The Reading class OE-10 applies to both VO-1000 and early DS4-4-1000 end cab switchers. While the majority of the switchers on the Reading where concintrated in the Philadelphia area, the OE-10’s were seen in all parts of the railroad including the Shamokin Division.
The first pair of VO-1000’s #80-81 arrived in August of 1940 and had ovel grills like they early VO-660’s.
Reading OE-10 #80 at Shamokin, PA
The next VO-1000’s to arrive looked very muck alike. They had curved walkway boards, point radaitor grills in the front and single exhaust stacks near the cab.
Reading OE-10 #78
In September of 1944 the Reading received #55-59, their last of their VO-1000’s from Baldwin. They differed from the earlier VO’s by having square cornered walkways.
Reading OE-10 #57 is an example of the later car body style for the VO-1000
Reading OE-10 #56
The next group to be delievered #34-36 were amoung the first group of DS4-4-1000’s to be built. According to the Baldwin book they were built with parts left over from the VO production. The #35 has a VO radiator.
Reading OE-10 DS4-4-1000 with a VO front end
The rest of the DS4-4-1000’s had flat radiators. The DS4-4-1000’s were delievered with four exhaust stacks.
During the war Baldwin had found that the exhaust back-pressure could be reduced with the four stack exhaust and it reduced the heat the generator was subjected to increasing its efficiency. Restrictions from the War Production Board prohibited making the change during the war to the VO-1000’s. After the war Baldwin recommended that the change be made to the VO-1000’s Reading did that to some of their locomotives during later overhauls.
References:
Diesel Era – 1996 March/April – Reading’s Repowered Switchers.
Diesel Era – 1998 March/April – Reading’s First-Generation Diesels by by Paul K. Withers
Reading Diesels Volume 1 The First Generation – by Dale Woodland Photograph’s from George Losse Collection scaned from negatives.
The Reading Company had been a long time buyer from Baldwin locomotive Works. They had bought steam locomotive from them and had been very happy with the diesel switchers made by Baldwin. When the railroad turn to the road switcher models they again turned to Baldwin and bought their AS-16 model.
There are good sources of information on these units in print. Here is a short list:
Diesels of the Reading Company Volume 1, Paul K. Withers
Reading Diesels Volume 1 The First Generation, Dale Woodland
While each group of AS-16’s were different they did have a few things in common. They all had walkways over the top of the vent in the roofs. Most had louvers on the engineer’s side of the long hood under the air intakes. They all had railroad applied rain gutters applied to the cab roofs.
All the AS-16’s were delivered in the Pullman Green paint scheme, and they wore it until they were retired. As delivered they had green handrails and low numbers on the ends of the locomotives. During sometime around 1953 the handrails were painted the safety yellow. Sometime near 1956 the end numbers started to move up on the end. I would imagine so that the tower operators could see the numbers.
The first group #530-537 arrived on the property from 7/51-9/51. They were straight freight locomotives without dynamic brakes. They had 900 gallon fuel tanks above the frame directly behind the cabs, leaving the space between the trucks under the locomotive open. Their bell’s were mounted at the top of the long hoods. The long hoods were forward.
The next four locomotives to arrive were 560-563 were dual controlled, steam generator equipped passenger locomotives. They were based out of Green Street engine house. Their 1000 gallon fuel tank was under the frame between the trucks. The 900 gallon tank behind the cab was used for water for the steam generator. The bell was still mounted on the end of the locomotive.
The next group of freight units #538-550 arrived 10/51-11/51. Externally they differed from the first group of freight units only in the moving of the bell from the end to under the frame on the fireman’s side of the front of the locomotive. Not visible to the modeler they were heavier than the first group by 1100 lbs.
The next group of AS-16’s #576-589 arrived on the property between 6/52-7/52. They were equipped with dynamic brakes in the short hood, the bell mounted under the frame, had a 1000 gallon fuel tank under the frame between the trucks and did not have a tank of the short hood end of the locomotive. In addition they were 1300 lbs. heavier than the last group of freight locomotives.
The grill work in the short hood for the dynamic brake required the number boards be moved up the car side to the top of the short hood.
The last group of Baldwins #551-554 arrived 10/53. The order started out a 10 units but the railroad cut the order to just four units. The six locomotives left over at Baldwin were later sold to the PRSL without the Dynamic brake equipment. This was also the first use of Baldwin’s new carbody design which had enough room to move the dynamic brake equipment into the long hood. This order went back to the use of the 900 gallon fuel tank behind the cab. leaving the space under the long hood between the trucks open.
One of the problems the railroad had with the Baldwins was that they could not MU with other locomotives. Worse than that, they could not even MU with each different order. The 1951 locomotives could not MU with the 1952 units until the railroad made modifications to the load regulators, costing the railroad $16,820 per unit for the modifications. This could also account for why early photos of the Baldwins show them MU’ing with other units from the same orders. The 1953 locomotives never were able to MU with the rest of the Baldwin fleet. They had electric throttles which aloud them to MU with other manufactures locomotives but not the other Baldwins.
Most of the photos that have been published have been of the units later in life. This is understandable as they replaced steam locomotives as they arrived and most railfans tried to capture what was going away instead of what was replacing it. Why not, the new units would be around for another 15 years? What few photos are around of the units in their first years show that changes came to them early. I’ve already pointed out the numbers on the ends move higher. The hand rails get painted with safety colors and also they added louvers under the long hood’s air intake on the engineer’s side of the locomotive. This appears to have happened in late 1952 or early 1953, after my modeling period of the Summer of 1952.
Below is a chart of the Baldwin AS-16 roster on the Reading. Some of the data is pulled from the Diesel Era article on the Reading AS-16’s and some from photos. Assignment refers to engine house assignments painted on the locomotive as seen is photos of the units.
No.
Built
DB
Bell
Fuel Tank
Assignment
530
7-51
–
Top
Walkway
StC
531
8-51
–
Top
Walkway
SH
532
8-51
–
Top
Walkway
G
533
8-51
–
Top
Walkway
CATA
534
9-51
–
Top
Walkway
G
535
9-51
–
Top
Walkway
536
9-51
–
Top
Walkway
SH
537
9-51
–
Top
Walkway
G
538
10-51
–
UF
Walkway
G
539
10-51
–
UF
Walkway
540
11-51
–
UF
Walkway
R
541
11-51
–
UF
Walkway
542
11-51
–
UF
Walkway
StC
543
11-51
–
UF
Walkway
G
544
11-51
–
UF
Walkway
SH
545
11-51
–
UF
Walkway
546
11-51
–
UF
Walkway
StC
547
11-51
–
UF
Walkway
548
11-51
–
UF
Walkway
549
11-51
–
UF
Walkway
550
11-51
–
UF
Walkway
StC
551
10-53
LH
UF
Walkway
552
10-53
LH
UF
Walkway
553
10-53
LH
UF
Walkway
554
10-53
LH
UF
Walkway
560
9-51
–
Top
UF
GS
561
9-51
–
Top
UF
GS
562
9-51
–
Top
UF
GS
563
9-51
–
Top
UF
GS
576
6-52
SH
UF
UF
577
6-52
SH
UF
UF
578
6-52
SH
UF
UF
579
6-52
SH
UF
UF
StC
580
6-52
SH
UF
UF
581
6-52
SH
UF
UF
StC
582
7-52
SH
UF
UF
583
7-52
SH
UF
UF
StC
584
7-52
SH
UF
UF
585
7-52
SH
UF
UF
StC
586
7-52
SH
UF
UF
StC
587
7-52
SH
UF
UF
StC
588
7-52
SH
UF
UF
589
7-52
SH
UF
UF
StC
References:
Diesels of the Reading Company Volume 1, Paul K. Withers
Diesel Era – 1991 September/October – Reading Baldwin AS-16 Road Switchers by Gerard E. Bernet.
Diesel Era – 1998 March/April – Reading’s First-Generation Diesels by by Paul K. Withers
Reading Diesels Volume 1 The First Generation – by Dale Woodland
Photograph’s from George Losse Collection either scanned from negatives or prints.
The story of the Reading K1 2-10-2 is told very well in a 16 page article in the May/June 1981 issue of Mainline Modeler by Bert Pennypacker “Reading 2-10-2 It should have been a Texas” I do not plan to go into all the details the article did, instead I’ll go over the highlights. There is an HO scale drawing of the K1sd in the center spread of the magazine.
The Reading 3000-series K1 started as a rebuilding program in 1927 with parts supplied by Baldwin. The first 11 locomotives were rebuilt in the Reading Shops from N1’s 2-8-8-2 which were built between 1917-1919. An additional ten locomotives (3011-3020) were built by Baldwin. The 3000-3009 were classed K1-sa, 3010 was classed K1-sc, and the 3011-3020 were classed K1-sb.
The 3010 was classed K1-sc because it was built with Caprotti valve gear. This proved to be troublesome to operate and costly to maintain. In 1942 it was replaced with the same Walscheart valve gear the others locomotives had and the 3010 was re-classed as K1-sa.
In 1945 while the Reading shops were busy building the T1 4-8-4’s the K1received some modernization changes including dynamically cross-balanced Baldwin disc main driving wheels, tapered main rods and high speed drifting valves. These changes where made to increase the K1’s potential speed from 50 to 60 m.p.h. making them similar to the new T-1’s. The locomotives were re-classed from K1-sa/b to K1-sd/e.
By 1948, the diesels arriving on the railroad started to bump the K1’s from their normal routes. They started to be reassigned into the coal regions and on the Shamokin Division.
The class survived intact until the first end of steam on the Reading in the beginning of 1954. The rebuilt K1’s were first to be retired in May of 1954. Followed by the Baldwin built locomotives in March of 1955. There were No survivors from the scrappers torch.
References:
Diesel Era – 1998 March/April – Reading’s First-Generation Diesels by by Paul K. Withers
FD&S – Vol. 12, No. 2 – Reading’s DF-2: TThe EMD F3 by Richard W. Jahn
Reading Diesels Volume 1 The First Generation – by Dale Woodland
The Revolutionary Diesel EMC’s FT – by Diesel ERA Photograph’s from George Losse Collection either scaned from negatives or prints.
Prototype History The H21 was originally designed as a 50 ton coke car. Construction of new H21 cars ran from 1909 through 1914. They were built by Altoona Car shops, Pressed Steel Car Co., Cambria Steel Co., American Car & Foundry, and Standard Steel Car Co.
A total of 21,738 car were built as the 50 ton H21 car class. It did not take long for the railroad to see that these cars had the capacity to hold 70 tons of coal. Lines West began converting the class into H21a’s in 1911. In 1912 the railroad began producing H22’s for coke service and converting the H21’s to handle coal. All H21’s would be converted to H21a by 1925. The conversion was basically placing 70 ton Crown trucks under the cars.
From 1915-1918 the railroad built an additional 14,270 H21a cars. The builders of the new cars were the same as for the H21’s with the addition of Ralston Steel Car Co. The railroad began to see that the frames were not able to hold up to the 70 ton coal loading. They began adding the reinforcement angle on the top sill from bolster to bolster starting in 1919. A corner to corner strengthened bulb angle would start appearing in the ’30’s but would not result in a class change. Nor would the conversion from original style “clamshell” hopper to “sawtooth” hoppers result in a class change.
The H21b class was created in 1930 when the railroad started a program to upgrade 100 cars with a 12 inch ARA center sill. This program was again done in 1943 to bring the total of H21b’s to 198. Externally there were no visible features to distingush the class besides the class stencil.
The H21d was a one-of-a-kind car conversition into a covered hopper car. While the H21d looks neat, I do not like to model one car classes. As I’ve pointed out before, most likely you would not have ever seen the car standing trackside in real life.
The class H21e first appeard in August of 1947 and reached a peak of 8,546 cars by January of 1953. The rebuild included adding a power hand brake and internal crossridge stakes. The power brakes had been applied to some H21a class cars without resulting in a class change. These H21a’s retained their internal cross ties at stakes 2, 4, 6, and 8. Some H21e car would have their side stakes welded on instead of the normal riveted side stakes.
In 1953 the PRR rostered 37173 class H21 hoppers. The OER did not fully split out the subclasses of “a”, “b” or “e.” Here are some fleet totals for the H21 class from 1952-1958 OER’s and the percentage that number represented to the total PRR open hopper fleet.
1952: 39702 cars 49.5% of the total PRR open hopper fleet
1953: 37173 cars 50.2% of the total PRR open hopper fleet
1956: 30737 cars 53.2% of the total PRR open hopper fleet
1958: 28020 cars 47.8% of the total PRR open hopper fleet
The PRR Steel Hopper book lists the following for class breakdowns for July of 1953: 35,256 total cars, 26576 H21a, 170 H21b, 1 H21d, 8509 h21e.
Cars of later subclasses are after my modeling time of 1952. I’ll let someone else talk about those classes.
References: Keystone Article PRR Steel Open Hopper Cars – John Teichmoeller January 1952 Official Railway Equipment Register September 1953 Official Railway Equipment Register April 1956 Official Railway Equipment Register
Modeling the H21’s in Proto48 In O scale we have been blessed with nice brass examples of the H21’s over the years. Some are clearly better, more accurate, or have finer details than others. And they have different price tags to go with them. The manufacturers of these cars are Precision Scale, Pacific Limited, Yoder Models and Keystone Model Works.
In recent years we have been blessed with a plastic version from Atlas O. While not a a finely detailed as some of the better brass car the cost about one sixth of the newest brass cars.
I hope to have additional posts about my modeling of these hopper cars.
On the trip back from the Cleveland Show in November, I had the chance to visit with Rob Enrico and see his Monogahela Division layout in person. I have to say that I seen his layout in print before but I wasn’t prepared for what it looks like in person. The photographs in print do not do it justice.
It’s actually a very simple layout if you look at the published plans. It’s basically a double track loop around his two car garage with a section across the middle for a yard area. What it may appear to lack because of the simplified track plan design, it makes up for in scenes that are recreated on the railroad. The rail fans on the overpass could have been my brother and me. Notice the fence posts.
Or this simple scene of a crewman walking out to his car at the end of the workday. How many times have we seen that rail fanning? But how many times have you seen it on a layout?
Here is Rob talking with Rich Yoder about freight car truck.