Prototype: Reading RS-2 #539 two photos

Reading 539 2/15/52
Reading 539 in Catawissa, PA 8/56

Just when you think you know something, you don’t!

 I’ve been looking at photographs and marking down the detail differences on the RS-2 page.
 
Before tonight I had only seen one photo of a Reading AS-16 without louvers on the Engineer’s side below the air intakes on the long hood. Tonight I found three more photos which clearly showed the panel on #538, 539 and 533 without louvers.
 
What is really making my head spin is that a photo of #539  dated 2/15/52 shows enginge number 539 without louvers and then less then four years lateer in 8/56 the same locomotive has the louvers.
 
Time to find more images of the locomotives in 1952!
 
 

Vulcan Trucks – Two Different Versions

Yoder P48 Vulcan truck on left, San Juan P48 Vulcan truck with Protocraft 33″ wheelset on right.

While at the Strasburg show I picked up a pair of the new Yoder Vulcan p48 trucks.  The Yoder website shows the trucks are out of stock in P48, but he had some on the table at the show. The trucks come fully assembled and include a screw so that they could be mounted onto one of Rich’s models.

I had held back before on buying these because I have several pair of San Juan’s Vulcan truck on the shelf and really did not know much about the design. When I got home and set the truck next to a San Juan truck, I was pleased to see that they were different. This started a little digging to find out some more information about the trucks.

I looked at the article “Arch Bars to Roller Bearing, Freight car trucks 1900-1960″ by Richard Hendrickson in Volume 4 of the Railway Prototype Cyclopedia. Where I found out the Vulcan truck was manufactured by American Steel Foundries in the early 1920′s. They were similiar to Andrews trucks of the time, with a cast steel side frame with seperate journal boxes.  Where they differed is that the Vulcan design eliminated the need for a bottom retainer bars by bolting the journal box into pedestal jaws.

The article show photos of two different Vulcan designs one an earlier L-section and one a later U-section side frame castings.

In Robert Karig’s book, Coal Cars the first three hundred years, he speaks of the Vulcan design in chapter six on Freight car trucks. “George G. Floyd was awarded a patent for a side frame with pedestal mounted journal boxes on May 3, 1910. It served as the foundation patent for the American Steel Foundries’ Vulcan side frame. Initially built in a T-Section form, the Vulcan frame was ultimately converted to a channel-section design.”

I was also surprised to see that Rich’s trucks were completly within NMRA spec for P48. Not all of the trucks I have measured before from Rich for Standard O scale were, so this was great news. The San Juan truck does have nice casting letting on the truck sideframes that the Yoder’s are lacking.

Vulcan Truck from 1922 Car Builders Cyclopedia

Vulcan truck with NYC markings on display at the Danbury Railroad Museum, Danbury, CT.

2011 Strasburg O Scale Show – August

Rich Yoder and John Dunn put on another O Scale Show in Strasburg on August 6, 2011. The show was very well attended and there were a number of new things to see at the show. One of the bigger items that was on a couple of tables was Weaver’s new Lackawanna Pocono 4-8-4, one of them is in the lead photo on theis post.

Rich Yoder also had his new Mathieson Dry Ice car.  I didn’t photograph the car because I was to busy going through his stock of trucks. One his table he had O scale and P48 versions of two new trucks, the PRR 2F-F2 and the PRR 2D-F12. I’ve added the measurements for the new trucks into the P48 Wheel Standards page.

I was also able to pick up an older Precision Scale Co. C&O 50 ton twin class H5 with flat ends. We had been talking about this car on the Proto48 modelers board. Turns out this car is correct for one order of theErieoffset twins and is different than the Yoder cars that are correct for theErie. I’ll post more on that later this week.

I had the chance to meet and talk for a while to Jack Hill at the show. It was very nice to put a face with the models that I’ve seen in his blog.

After a nice morning of buying and selling, I had the pleasure of going to lunch at Jenny’s Diner on US 30 with other p48′ers, such as Martin Latowsky. That is starting to turn into a regular P48 Lunch outing.

Reading Modeling Myth #1-Will the “Real” RDG Pullman Green Please Stand Up – Part III

The plot thickens……

My brother Bobb sent this partial scan to tease me a little today. It’s from a lettering diagram for Reading and CNJ switchers. The drawing was first released on 12/7/38 and is updated through 1944.

It does identify “Duco Pullman Green -(Reading Railroad Standard)- No. 254-1374″

Now to research the modern version of that paint. Still might not be what’s on the AS-16′s, but it’s another step closer.

PRR Class GLa Open Hopper

PRR 166658 GLa

PRR 166658 GLa – George Losse collection

The Pennsylvania Railroad class GLa is a 50 ton twin open hopper car. Construction began in 1904 and continued through 1991. A total of 30,256 were built for the PRR or acquired from various coal companies that built the same design.

The April 1956 OER lists 21,840 GLa’s on the roster. Compare this to Reading’s 13015 total hopper cars, or Western Maryland’s 8006 total hopper cars and you begin to see the size of the PRR fleet of GLa’s.

The GLa was originally built with K brakes and later converted to AB. Very few GLa were updated with power brake wheels most cars retained their verticle brake staff. One exception would be the second hand cars acquired from Berwind-White, which had modern power hand brake hardware.

It’s interesting to note that the overall dimensions of the GLa are close to the USRA Standard 50-Ton Twin Hopper which was designed almost 15 years later. Inside Length is one inch shorter at 30′ 5″. Inside width 9′ 5 1/2″ is a half an inch wider then the USRA Twin. The GLa is 8″ shorter to the top of side cord at 10′ 0″ but the side height is only 5″ shorter as the bottom of the car side sits three inches lower than the USRA Twin. The GLa has a capacity only 197 cu. ft. less that the USRA Twin. These similiarities will work in our favor when it comes time to build a fleet of these cars.

BCWX 4026 GLa

BCWX 4026 GLa – George Losse collection

WMX 1404 GLa

WMX 1404 GLa – George Losse collection

References:
Keystone Article
PRR Steel Open Hopper Cars – John Teichmoeller
January 1952 Official Railway Equipment Register
September 1953 Official Railway Equipment Register
April 1956 Official Railway Equipment Register

1941 AAR 50-ton 53′ 6″ Flat Car

O Scale Models:
Chooch #674 Pullman Flat Car – Ultra Scale line of resin cars.
Wiseman Model Services appears to be producing a similar kit.

The History:
The American Association of Railroads (AAR) Committee on Car Construction established a standard for 53’ 6” flat cars based upon a 1941 Pullman-Standard Company design. The earliest users of this design were the Chicago Great Western, Monon, Soo and UP. The design established a new standard for deck height of 42” which was lower than previous car designs. This feature would permit taller loads without exceeding established clearance limits. It also had a much wider deck extending beyond the fishbelly sides. Twenty railroads built 2532 cars to this basic design.

The car spanned a long period of operation ranging from 1941 to the 1980’s. Some roads converted these cars into piggyback carriers or fitted them with bulkheads for building materials. Many of the cars ended up in maintenance of way service after a long revenue life.

Following chart from Chooch website:

Roster of 53′ 6″ Flat Cars
Owner Number Series # Built Year Built Builder
Atlantic Coast Line 77000-77099 172 1943 Greenville
77172-77471 300 1943 Pullman
Chesapeake & Ohio 80625-80724 100 1944 Ralston
Chicago Great Western 3800-3899 100 1940 Pullman
3900-3999 100 1944 Pullman
C I & L (Monon) 7000-7059 60 1941 Pullman
7201-7250 50 1944 Greenville
C&NW 44001-44599 300 1946 Mt. Vernon
45601-46099 250 1942 Pullman
46101-46599 250 1944 Pullman
Clinchfield 10100-10149 50 1946 AC&F
D&RGW 22000-22199 200 1944 Mt. Vernon
22200-22249 50 1951 RR Shops
EJ&E 6375-6574 200 1942 Ralston
6575-6774 200 1947 AC&F
I-GN (Missouri Pacific) 8500-8599 100 1943 AC&F
Illinois Terminal 100-1149 50 1945 AC&F
Kansas City Southern 1000-1199 200 1954 AC&F
Louisville & Nashville 21000-21099 100 1943 AC&F
2100-21399 300 1947 Greenville
Minneapolis & St. Louis 23501-23799 150 1945 RR Shops
23801-23999 100 1952 GATC
Nickel Plate Road 3000-3049 50 1942 Pullman
Northern Pacific 62000-62299 300 1943 AC&F
Rock Island 91100-91599 500 1951 Pullman
Soo Line 5201-5399 100 1941 Pullman
St. L SW (Cotton Belt) 8500-85074 75 1955 Greenville
85075-85124 50 1957 Greenville
Union Pacific 57000-57299 300 1941 Pullman
Western Maryland 2301-2325 25 1943 AC&F

* Information off of the Chooch website

Pullman PS-1 40 Ft Boxcars in 1952

lv-62000

Pullman Standard introduced its PS-1 boxcar in the late 1947. There are a number of articles about the PS-1’s in the Hobby press. I’m not going to restate everything that has been written about this design of cars.

Ed Hawkins and Ted Culotta compiled a list of all the PS-1’s built. The complete list of Pullman PS-1 boxcars can be found on the Steam Era Freight Car Website.

Below is a modified version of their information sorted by the build-date of the cars built before my modeling period, the Summer of 1952.

Pullman Standard built a total of 77,570 cars, but by 7/52 only 46,847 had been built. These are the only cars that existed and could have been seen by my modeling period, so this is a list of the only cars that can be on the layout. Now I don’t plan to build every one of these, but the four or five I do plan to build are on this list.

This will also give me other other information then just what details are on the car and which road. By knowing if the car is less than one year old it means it should look close to brand new. Or if it’s one of the LV car built in 1947 it should look like it has been in service for five years.

Lionel and Weaver both make version of this car in O scale. The Lionel car is available with a 6ft, 7ft and 8ft door. The Weaver is only available with an 8ft door. Protocraft makes a number of decals for these cars, I’ve linked the reporting mark (first column) to the decal pages with photos of the cars.

Road Series Qty Built Lot No. Door Type Trucks
LV 62000-62499 500 6-47 5873 7 7P Sup1 S2(SP)
CGW 93001-93500 500 8-47 5875 6 7P Sup1 S2A
BM 74000-74499 500 9-47 5877 7 7P Sup1 A3
MEC 6500-6749 250 10-47 5877 7 7P Sup1 A3
ATSF 276500-276749 250 11-47 5879 6 7P Sup1 A3
NH 34000-34499 500 11-47 5894 7 7P Sup1 A3
NH 33500-33999 500 12-47 5882 7 7P Sup1 A3
KCS 18150-18549 400 12-47 5885 6 7P Sup1 A3
NKP 6600-6999 400 J-48 5887A 7 7P Sup1 A3
C&O 15000-15999 1000 2-48 5886 6 7P Sup1 A3
NKP 6000-6599 600 2-48 5887 7 7P Sup1 A3
Southern 23487-26486 3000 2-48 5896 8 7P Sup1 S2A
KCS 18550-18949 400 3-48 5895 6 7P Sup1 A3*
NYC 167000-167999 1000 3-48 5904 6 7P Sup1 S2A*
SAL 22450-22949 500 4-48 5888 14 7P Sup1 A3
NH 34500-34999 500 4-48 5894 7 7P Sup1 A3
NH 35000-35999 1000 4-48 5907 7 7P Sup1 A3
UP 100000-101599 1600 6-48 5908 6 7P Sup2 S2A
SL-SF 17000-17299 300 7-48 5911 8 7P Sup2 A3
RI 25500-26499 1000 8-48 5919 6 7P Sup2 A3
COPR 4010-4024 15 8-48 5908A 6 7P Sup2 S2A
CNW 86300-88298 1000 9-48 5920 6 7P Sup2 A3
SA 8200-8249 50 9-48 5896A 8 7P Sup1 ANDREWS
SAL 24000-24499 500 10-48 5919B 8 7P Sup2 A3
CMO 39100-39498 200 11-48 5919A 6 7P Sup2 A3
CNW 88300-88382 42 11-48 5919A 6 7P Sup2 A3
COPR 4025-4032 8 11-48 5919A 6 7P Sup2 A3
DSS&A 15000-15099 100 11-48 5919A 6 7P Sup2 A3
P&WV 1300-1399 100 11-48 5919A 6 7P Sup2 A3
DL&W 35000-35199 200 12-48 5936 6 7P Sup2 S2A
Southern 26487-26527 41 12-48 5919A 6 7P Sup2 A3?
Southern 262050-262055 6 12-48 5919A 6 7P Sup2 A3
Southern 307023-307024 2 12-48 5919A 6 7P Sup2 A3?
Southern 330500 only 1 12-48 5919A 6 7P Sup2 A3?
MSC 5000-5099 100 6-49 5942 6 YSD-2 A3
CIL 501-530 30 6-49 5942A 6 YSD-2 A3
CP 269600-269999 400 7-49 5950 6 YSD-2 S2A
LS&BC 1100-1119 20 8-49 5950 6 YSD-2 S2A
CNW 106600-108598 1000 8-49 5955 6 YSD-2 A3
CIL 532 only 1 10-49 5950 6 YSD-2 S2A
MKT 90001-90079 79 10-49 5950 6 YSD-2 S2A
CNW 57400-57898 250 11-49 5957 15 YSD-2 A3
NYC 169750-170499 750 J-50 5965 6 YSD-2
ATSF 31250-31749 500 5-50 5964 6 YSD-2A A3
L&N 16800-17299 500 5-50 5966A 6 YSD-2 A3
L&N 17300-17799 500 6-50 5966B 6 7P Sup3 A3
NYC 169000-169749 750 7-50 5965 6 7P Sup3 A3*
LV 62500-62999 500 9-50 5970 7 7P Sup3 A3
LS&I 2226-2275 50 9-50 5965A 6 7P Sup3 A3
D&H 18400-18899 500 10-50 5973 6 YSD-2 A3*
GBW 700-899 200 11-50 5977 6 7P Sup3 A3
USAX 26021-26120 100 12-50 5980 8 7P Sup3 A3
C&O 16000-16999 1000 12-50 5983 8 YSD-2 A3
L&N 14600-14999 400 J-51 5988 6 YSD-2 A3
NYC 171000-171499 500 J-51 5993 6 7P Sup3
NYC 172000-172499 500 J-51 5997 6 YSD-2
NYC 170500-170999 500 2-51 5993 6 YSD-2 A3*
C&EI 65500-65699 200 2-51 5996 6 7P Sup3 A3
D&H 18900-19399 500 2-51 5998 6 YSD-2 A3*
USAX 26125-26318 194 3-51 8008 8 7P Sup3 A3
BM 75000-75749 750 4-51 5999 7 YSD-2 A3
SAL 24500-24999 500 5-51 5994 8 YSD-2 A3
NYC 171500-171999 500 5-51 5997 6 7P Sup3 A3*
MEC 8000-8249 250 5-51 5999A 7 YSD-2 A3
SL-SF 17300-17799 500 6-51 5995 8 YSD-2 A3
N&W 44000-44499 500 6-51 8002 8 YSD-2 A3*
ACY 700-849 150 6-51 8004 6 YSD-2 A3
CGW 5001-5600 600 6-51 8016 6 YSD-2 S2A
CNW 6200-7398 600 7-51 8007 6 7P Sup3 A3
CNW 7400-10198 1400 7-51 8007 6 YSD-2 A3
USAFX 26319-26323 5 7-51 8044 8 YSD-2 A3
USAFX 26474-26481 8 7-51 8044 8 YSD-2
USAX 26324-26473 150 7-51 8044 8 YSD-2
USMC 173227-173236 10 7-51 8044 8 YSD-2 A3
USN 02455-02463 9 7-51 8044 8 YSD-2 A3
USN 02698-02727 30 7-51 8044 8 YSD-2
C&O 17000-17999 1000 9-51 8017 8 YSD-2 A3
L&N 17800-18399 600 10-51 5988 6 YSD-2 A3
MILW 35000-35041 42 10-51 8025 6 7P Sup3 S2A*
SSW 33950-34049 100 10-51 8026 8 YSD-2 A3
WP 20801-20820 20 10-51 8027 7 YSD-2 A3
WP 20821-21400 580 10-51 8027 7 YSD-2 A3
Southern 30000-30499 500 11-51 8003 9 YSD-2 S2A
Southern 30500-32018 1519 11-51 8003 9 7P Sup3
Southern 262056-262059 4 11-51 8003 8 7P Sup3
Southern 307028 only 1 11-51 8003 8 7P Sup3
Southern 330501 only 1 11-51 8003 8 7P Sup3
RI 21000-21749 750 11-51 8028 6 7P Sup3 S2A
RI 21750-22249 500 11-51 8028 6 YSD-2 S2A
RI 22250-22999 750 12-51 8028 6 7P Sup3 S2A*
L&C 1000-1019 20 1-52 8003 9 7P Sup3 S2A
BS 6700-6749 50 1-52 8009 6 7P Sup3 S2A
CNW 6766 only 1 J-52 8083 6 5P Sup
CNW Various 3 J-52 8083 6 5P Sup
BS 6750-6799 50 2-52 8009 6 PS S2A
NC&StL 22000-22649 650 2-52 8015 6 YSD-2 A3
N&W 44500-44999 500 2-52 8035 8 YSD-2 S2A*
GA 39501-39550 50 3-52 8021 6 YSD-2 A3
WofA 18100-18209 110 3-52 8021 6 YSD-2 A3
SAL 25000-25499 500 3-52 8029 8 YSD-2 A3
L&N 5000-7199 2200 3-52 8039 8 YSD-2 A3
CG 7000-7299 300 4-52 8030 8 YSD-2 S2A
C&O 18000-18499 500 6-52 8037 8 YSD-2 S2A
C&O 18500-18999 500 6-52 8037 8 6P Sup1 S2A
ASX 712-811 100 6-52 8069 6 5P Sup A3
NYC 180000-180499 500 6-52 8036A 6 5P Sup A3
BCK 1000-1499 500 7-52 8038 7 5P Sup A3
FDDM&S 12201-12400 200 7-52 8036B 6 5P Sup A3
CP 268800-269099 300 7-52 8036C 6 5P Sup S2A
LS&I 2400-2489 90 8-52 8047 8 YSD-2 A3
VGN 63100-63399 300 8-52 8048 8 YSD-2 A3/S2B

References:
Ed Hawkins PS-1 list on the Steam Era Freight Car Website
Mainline Modeler Article

Reading N1’s 2-8-8-0

Reading N1-sc 1813 in an as-built look.

Bert Pennypacker speaks about the Reading Mallets 2-8-8-2 in his Mainline Modeler article on the K1’s. They were built by Baldwin beginning with six locomotives received in 1917. Two additional orders brought the fleet up to 31 locomotives by 1919 and were classes N1-sa/b/c. They were numbered 1800-1830, with 55.5 inch drivers and 98,400 lbs of tractive force.

The mallets were distributed in different parts of the system, 11 were running between Hagerstown-Rutherford-Allentown, two were assigned to Reading as Temple Hill pushers, and the rest were were distributed through the coal regions, West Cressona, St.Clair, Tamaqua, Gordon and Shamokin. The locomotives assigned to pusher duties were given small capacity tenders, 8,000 gallons and12.8 tons of coal. While the road mallets were given larger tenders with 11,000 gallon and 18 ton capacity. Wages were cheap and pusher runs were short, no need for big tenders.

It was said of the Mallets that they could pull anything slowly. The Reading most not have been totally happy with the speed of the N1’s in road service. Beginning in 1927, locomotives #1800-1810 (11) were rebuilt into the K1 2-10-2 locomotives. They were only ten years old at the start of the project. Their boilers were reused and most of their parts in the rebuilding project.

Reading N1 drawing from Locomotive Cyclopedia

Then in 1930 the railroad began converting the mallets from compound to single expansion cylinders. They were re-classed as N1-sd. The big delivery pipes on the side of the smoke box are an indication of the converted locomotives. All the N1’s were converted by 1945. They also had their trailing trucks removed between 1940-1944.

Reading N1-sd moving a train in coal country.

In the late 1940’s ten N1-sd’s received new smoke boxes and cross-compound air pumps relocated onto the smoke box front. The locomotive that had the forward mounted air pumps were numbered; 1811, 1812, 1817, 1820, 1822, 1823, 1826, 1828, 1829 and 1830.

Reading N1-sd sporting air pumps on the smoke box

Reading 1814 N1-sd on the move.

Nice to have both sides of Reading1814 here at Tamaqua, PA.

References:
Mainline Modeler, May/June 1981 – “Reading 2-10-2 It should have been a Texas” by Bert Pennypacker
Reading Steam Pictorial

Photograph’s from George Losse Collection scanned from prints and/or original negatives.

Reading OE-9 EMD NW2

Reading OE-9  #102 Tamaqua, PA 9/23/1961

Reading OE-9 #102 Tamaqua, PA 9/23/1961

The Reading received their first 1000 HP. switcher form EMD in the form of an NW2 #90, on September 5, 1940. This missed out being the first 1000 HP. switcher on the Reading by three weeks to #80 a Baldwind VO-1000.

NW2’s numbered #91-92 arrived in early October of 1941. After World War 2 was over the Reading added five more NW2’s to the roster numbers #100-104.The second series of NW2’s differed slightly from the first three by having louvers in the engine compartment doors.

The First three were originally assigned to the Shamokin Division. Eventually, they migrated to other parts of the railroad.

All the locomotives were delievered in the Pullman Green scheme. None were repainted into the green and Yellow scheme. One locomotive #104 was repainted into the last solid green scheme. Not all switcher received the rain gutters, #91 was photographed in 1963 without gutters.

Reading OE-9 #92 Reading, PA 10-16-75

Reading OE-9 #92 Reading, PA 10-16-75

No. Built Model Notes Engine House Assignment Photos on this Site Photo Online
90 Sep-40 NW2 No Louvers PhotoPhoto
91 Oct-41 NW2 No Louvers Photo
92 Oct-41 NW2 No Louvers PhotoPhoto
100 Jul-47 NW2 Louvers PhotoPhoto
101 Jul-47 NW2 Louvers PhotoPhoto
102 Jul-47 NW2 Louvers
103 Jul-47 NW2 Louvers
104 Jul-47 NW2 Louvers PhotoPhotoPhoto

References:
Diesel Era – 1996 March/April – Reading’s Repowered Switchers.
Diesel Era – 1998 March/April – Reading’s First-Generation Diesels by by Paul K. Withers
Reading Diesels Volume 1 The First Generation – by Dale Woodland
Photograph’s from George Losse Collection scaned from negatives.